Authors at Texas Book Festival Say Forgetting History Allows Injustice to Repeat
By Gabrielle Caumon
Reporting Texas

Authors Daniel Peña, left, and Jazmine Ulloa, center, discuss immigration issues at the Texas Book Festival with moderator Stephane Valle. Gabrielle Caumon/Reporting Texas
When Renée Good and Alex Pretti were fatally shot by federal immigration agents this year in Minneapolis, some described the events as unprecedented in American history, but the tactics used by immigration officers today have a much longer history, New York Times reporter and author Jazmine Ulloa said at the Texas Book Festival.
“If you look at what I wrote and the history of immigration policy and the detention system, you’ll see that a lot of those tactics originated on the southern border and were tested on the southern border,” said Ulloa, a University of Texas graduate and former reporter at the Austin American-Statesman.
At the Texas Book Festival on Saturday, Ulloa and fellow author Daniel Peña discussed how immigration enforcement, racial profiling and white supremacist rhetoric have shaped American history.
“It’s realizing that really the system is just coming back to its roots, its origins,” Ulloa said.
Their conversation focused on the consequences of forgetting that history.
The same concern emerged during a separate book festival panel with poet Emmy Pérez, who discussed how her work attempts to recover the histories of Mexican-American communities that were left out of her education.
“Growing up in the ‘70s and the ‘80s, they didn’t teach us our history — and they still don’t, right? Unless you’re very fortunate,” Pérez said. “So my whole adult life, I have tried to learn everything that my education beyond the home didn’t teach me.”
Ulloa said that research for her book “El Paso” turned up hundreds of mugshots of Chinese laborers detained under the first U.S. race-based exclusionary immigration laws, which dated to the 1870s-80s.
Some of these men argued in their legal documents that they were not illegal immigrants but U.S. citizens, born in cities like New York, San Francisco and Chicago. One man said he was born in San Francisco and was being illegally confined in El Paso. Ulloa said the discovery was a reminder that even citizenship did not necessarily protect people considered outsiders from immigration enforcement.
Ulloa said the U.S. detention and deportation system has been shaped by both Republican and Democratic administrations, with conservative candidates in recent years describing immigration as an “invasion.”
“These were candidates who were near and far from the border in positions of power that had nothing to do with federal policy on immigration, who were decrying this ‘invasion’ at the border,” Ulloa said.
Ulloa compared President Donald Trump and his allies’ 2024 promise of the largest mass deportation project in the nation’s history to the 1950s Eisenhower administration deportation campaign, known as Operation Wetback.
“And if you know anything about that, you know that it’s named after an ethnic slur,” Ulloa said.
That initiative was designed to remove undocumented Mexicans from the United States. The Border Patrol recorded more than 1 million apprehensions in 1954.
“I was talking to Latino and Latina Republicans, and so many people did not know about that chapter in American history,” Ulloa said. “I had one young Latina Republican laugh at me when I told her it was called Operation Wetback. She was like: No way is a deportation project going to be called something that offensive.”
Ulloa connected current immigration enforcement and rhetoric to the 1920s and 1930s, when immigration enforcement expanded alongside the eugenics movement.
“There was a lot of talk about white dominance, where Mexicanos were seen as inferior and dirty,” Ulloa said. “That’s where you saw these immigration checkpoints expanded into what they called bathhouses, where poor Mexican workers were doused with chemicals because they were seen as dirty and lice-carrying agents.”
Peña said the rise of white supremacist groups in the 1920s also echoes in contemporary America. He has explored how rhetoric about protecting white women and children has historically been used to justify violence against other groups, including the treatment of Comanche people.
He described the society’s growing acceptance of violence against marginalized people, including immigrants, as a “debasement ritual,” asking, “how have we become so OK by ritually consuming the pain of others?”
Ulloa said keeping the border “dark and scary” means overlooking the people who helped shape the region.
“Then we don’t see the workers and intellectuals who came into the United States and helped build the Southwest the way it is,” Ulloa said. “We don’t see the black people who saw the border as a line of freedom. That’s what we lose when we forget.”
For her book, Ulloa returned to her hometown of El Paso after the first anniversary of the 2019 Walmart mass shooting, one of the deadliest attacks on Latinos in modern history.
Ulloa said El Paso is often portrayed through the lens of national security, the drug war and violence. But she remembers seeing the city blend into Ciudad Juárez with her friends from the hills.
“We moved back and forth between cultures, languages, worlds,” Ulloa said.
She described the city as a critical mountain pass in the Chihuahuan Desert, on land that was “Mexican before it was American, that was indigenous before it was Spanish.”
“It’s really here that you can see that there is no such thing as a Hispanic invasion of the United States, as this self-proclaimed white supremacist declared in that screed that we’re talking about,” Ulloa said. “Because Mexican culture and history have always been part of who we are as Americans.”
Ulloa said her mother and grandmother wanted her to know as much Mexican history as American history and to speak both English and Spanish. Some of her friends, however, had parents who discouraged them from speaking Spanish so they would not “be seen as different by others in American classrooms.”
That effort to preserve family and community histories also runs through Pérez’s work.
Pérez described growing up hearing stories from her parents about their lives in the Texas and California borderlands: their homes, the canals where they swam, the land that sustained them and the poverty they experienced.
“That’s something that all of us can do,” Pérez said. “We can ask our elders and our neighbors to tell us their stories.”